🔗 Share this article

At an opulent speakeasy-style event at the Raffles hotel on Whitehall recently, the great and the good of what is left within Tory circles marked the Spectator’s parliamentarian of the year awards.

Given the publication's stance continuing to support the Conservatives, despite the party facing an existential crisis from Reform UK, it was unsurprising that speculation swirled during the upscale reception focused on the security of the leader's position faced threats.

Leadership Tensions Surface at Awards

James Cleverly, a former leadership contender, made pointed remarks during his speech targeting the obvious aspirations of his shadow cabinet colleague, a key rival – who is Badenoch’s biggest threat.

“Do I seek her position? Will I make a move against the leader and steal the crown? Certainly not,” the experienced politician informed the amused crowd as he opened the awards ceremony.

Jenrick, who came second, and has been pitching alarmingly to the right to take on Nigel Farage, did at least manage to chuckle. His strategic moves are far from discreet.

Countdown to Challenge Starts

Months ago, one of the Tory leader’s disgruntled backbenchers set up a countdown clock online showing remaining time before party regulations permit rivals to mount a challenge. That clock reaches zero this weekend.

From then on, opponents within the party can formally request to trigger a contest. Revised guidelines established recently to increase the threshold, now demanding thirty percent of the party’s 119 MPs are now needed, previously just fifteen percent, establishing a tougher standard for those trying to oust her.

Potential Contenders and Backing

Is it feasible for opponents – primarily Jenrick – persuade the 36 MPs required to start the process? Tory insiders point to previous nomination totals in the leadership contest: twenty-eight initially. “That’s your starting point,” they said.

There is no shortage of Tory MPs willing to share dissatisfaction with the leader: her approach, her political judgment, her ability to cut through. But, for the most part, they are hesitant about committing yet another act of political regicide so soon.

Respite and Election Anxieties

Some Conservative MPs further think her performance at the autumn party conference, unveiling plans of abolishing stamp duty for main residences, has bought her temporary relief.

“Although dissatisfied with the current leadership we will act cautiously regarding a change. The public already think we engage in internal conflicts. We don’t need to give them further confirmation,” an anonymous legislator stated.

This doesn't mean the plotting is not under way. “The leader has until spring. The local elections are going to be cataclysmic for us. Nobody is going to want to take over before that and have to own the result. But afterwards, we must find a leader capable of guiding in a new direction,” a frontbench source commented.

Survey Figures and Public Perception

The polls already suggest Badenoch has made little progress with the public in the past twelve months and that she has fallen in personal approval. At -22 points, her standing is lower than Jenrick (-16) and Mel Stride (-21), according to Ipsos Mori.

Data from YouGov further reveals that Badenoch has convinced just one in eight voters she is a prime minister in waiting. However, the picture is better with party supporters, with 54% saying they approve of her performance in her role, with fewer than a third opposing her continuation the party into the next general election.

Upcoming Scenarios and Party Dynamics

But while Tory supporters are ambivalent, there appears to be a consensus within parliamentary ranks that Badenoch will not be the one to lead the party into the next election.

The main division centers on timing to replace her in May and have a chance at stopping Reform’s momentum – or leave it until closer to the general election if Reform falters, and public receptiveness improves toward Conservative messages.

Widely known that Jenrick thinks he is the man for the job. However, associates claim he won't act immediately, and is among those who thinks they should wait until May.

Other Candidates and Strategies

There is also a theory that the party’s potential saviour from less expected with a lower profile (the shadow climate secretary is sometimes suggested) or among newer MPs with less obvious links to the party’s time in power.

Cleverly, who came third, is also cited as a potentially unifying figure, remaining reserved. His allies say he thinks there is no alternative than current leadership, since a new leader immediately would inherit an even more difficult situation.

However, if a contest were to be triggered, there would undoubtedly be those encourage his candidacy, and he might reconsider to give it another shot. A small group moderate legislators are already preparing opposition efforts to prevent Jenrick from being crowned leader in any eventual contest.

Conservative Movement and Electoral Calculations

A well-connected Tory cautioned that momentum favors right-wingers both inside and outside the party, citing figures such as Jenrick, Neil O’Brien, Katie Lam and Nick Timothy. “Opportunity exists for Cleverly given his experience and membership connections, while others oppose Jenrick completely.”

“Quite a lot of minds are on the need for a pact or coalition with Reform at some stage. Recent parliamentary divisions regarding social issues generated significant calls for expulsion of dissenters while Reform privately suggests Liberal Democrat sympathizers must go. That tips things the challenger slightly.”

However, another added: “Jenrick winning is not a foregone conclusion. We could have a strong competition between Jenrick and another – Cleverly, Stride. The idea that the rightwing candidate always wins the membership may not hold true.”